Does Anyone Actually Like Isekai?
Aug. 2nd, 2026 12:27 pmThe other day, I found an anime I'd never heard of, started it, and loved it. (Journal with Witch.) "They ARE still making decent anime!!" I cried with relief. And then I saw it: a calendar in one shot, that read "2018.” Sure enough, it came out years ago, because of course. Since no, they're not still making good anime.
Anime has been a huge part of my life for over two decades. (Or, if you count all the Voltron I watched in my youth, far longer than that.)
I went to anime for deeply emotional stories. I went to it for tremendous creativity in animation styles, which exploded in quality over those two decades. And I went to it for stories that weren't being told in Western media, both because it originated from a unique culture with its own unique perspective on life, social mores, the spiritual, etc., and also because -- at least until the isekai plague hit -- original ideas were greenlit for anime that would never be greenlit in the West.
Anime was fun and an inspiration and a comfort. It injected a tremendous amount of welcome originality into my viewing, as the output of TV in the West had become cliched, predictable, and safe. A thousand reboots later, American TV almost never surprised or thrilled me or made me feel much anymore.
I turned to anime because I knew all the Western tropes by heart already, not because I wanted to see Japan's take on Western tropes that were played out decades ago. I saw Tron when it came out (and it wasn't that great then); I didn't need another sucked-into-a-video-game story (none of which have been that great as anime, either, from what I've seen). If I wanted to experience yet another long journey with humans and elves and dwarves, I'd go play D&D. And aren't we on our 8th incarnation of "I was reincarnated as a 💩 but turns out I was a 💩 in my last life, too!"?
When I fruitlessly skim Reddit threads for anime recommendations, praying I've somehow overlooked something good, I get this "I can't believe the TV they make me watch" vibe, like just like me, they know they like anime, so they keep watching, but they haven't found themselves actually enjoying much of anything in a long time.
In just the last year or two, half-baked romance has been added to the previously all -isekai-all-the-time diet, which romance usually has a decent premise that grows stale within a few episodes. Aside from Wind Breaker and Apothecary Diaries, what truly excellent anime have even come out since 2023 that are not isekai (and now, the half-baked romance) or that didn't begin production before that year like My Hero Academia and Mob Psycho 100? There's a small percentage of shows that doesn't fully fall into either the isekai or romance categories (though usually close enough), but nothing stellar. Every time I see a list of anime people think is truly great, the animes always came out before that fateful year (except people really seem to like Frieren).
Am I the only one out here who doesn't even bother to look at the list of upcoming anime anymore because I already know exactly the genre and quality of just about everything that's going to be on it? My little otaku heart cries for the good old days when multiple truly excellent, creative, original animes came out every year.
Anime has been a huge part of my life for over two decades. (Or, if you count all the Voltron I watched in my youth, far longer than that.)
I went to anime for deeply emotional stories. I went to it for tremendous creativity in animation styles, which exploded in quality over those two decades. And I went to it for stories that weren't being told in Western media, both because it originated from a unique culture with its own unique perspective on life, social mores, the spiritual, etc., and also because -- at least until the isekai plague hit -- original ideas were greenlit for anime that would never be greenlit in the West.
Anime was fun and an inspiration and a comfort. It injected a tremendous amount of welcome originality into my viewing, as the output of TV in the West had become cliched, predictable, and safe. A thousand reboots later, American TV almost never surprised or thrilled me or made me feel much anymore.
I turned to anime because I knew all the Western tropes by heart already, not because I wanted to see Japan's take on Western tropes that were played out decades ago. I saw Tron when it came out (and it wasn't that great then); I didn't need another sucked-into-a-video-game story (none of which have been that great as anime, either, from what I've seen). If I wanted to experience yet another long journey with humans and elves and dwarves, I'd go play D&D. And aren't we on our 8th incarnation of "I was reincarnated as a 💩 but turns out I was a 💩 in my last life, too!"?
When I fruitlessly skim Reddit threads for anime recommendations, praying I've somehow overlooked something good, I get this "I can't believe the TV they make me watch" vibe, like just like me, they know they like anime, so they keep watching, but they haven't found themselves actually enjoying much of anything in a long time.
In just the last year or two, half-baked romance has been added to the previously all -isekai-all-the-time diet, which romance usually has a decent premise that grows stale within a few episodes. Aside from Wind Breaker and Apothecary Diaries, what truly excellent anime have even come out since 2023 that are not isekai (and now, the half-baked romance) or that didn't begin production before that year like My Hero Academia and Mob Psycho 100? There's a small percentage of shows that doesn't fully fall into either the isekai or romance categories (though usually close enough), but nothing stellar. Every time I see a list of anime people think is truly great, the animes always came out before that fateful year (except people really seem to like Frieren).
Am I the only one out here who doesn't even bother to look at the list of upcoming anime anymore because I already know exactly the genre and quality of just about everything that's going to be on it? My little otaku heart cries for the good old days when multiple truly excellent, creative, original animes came out every year.
