I love it, too. I always assumed it was the brother thing that squicked me out about Sam/Dean, but then like I said, Jared's character in Christmas Cottage with his brother was HOT, so maybe that's not it (or maybe I just buy Sam and Dean as brothers WAAAY more than I do those characters in Christmas Cottage). But, even if I ain't up for reading true Wincest, I think the subtext in the show is a ball, no matter who it's shipping ...